[What do you do when you can't sleep? I read and write.]
Saturday
Morning Reflections
We
who do not want to see a physical wall built between our country and Mexico
must be careful not to build a social wall between ourselves and the Americans
whose different views and votes carried the day on Tuesday, because “They” are not a
homogeneous block but a diverse group, with diverse reasons for voting as they
did.
·
Some
are party loyalists and would have voted for the Republican candidate
whoever he or she had been, and a certain segment of Republican party loyalists
are of the all-government-is-bad stripe. (Ideologically, they are
libertarians.) This group will always vote their ideology.
·
Others
are one-issue voters (e.g., anti-abortion). One friend told me her group
of Catholic women friends fall into this camp. All other issues, all other
statements were unimportant to them.
·
Some
“liked some of what he had to say” (e.g., “he talked about jobs”) enough
that they could somehow set aside the rest. One woman told me she tried, in
looking at both candidates, to set aside personality and character and look
only at issues. Apparently there were people who could do that.
·
A
very large segment flocked to the Republican Party because they had been
feeling invisible and the Republican candidate paid attention to them.
Most of the people in this group (amazingly! This came out in post-election
coverage) won’t even care all that much if he fails to make good on his
promises. Mobilization of the overlooked (overlooked by media and by mainstream
politicos alike) is the #1 explanation favored by mainstream journalists in the
election aftermath. I say it is significant, but it can only serve, in my view,
as one explanation among others. We human beings crave simple explanations, but
life is not always simple. Yes, this is an important factor (and we must all
draw a lesson from it), but it is not the only factor.
·
Don’t
forget that many who supported Bernie Sanders in the primary voted Republican
in the election! Crossover vote from Democrat to Republican accounts for
people (1) who believe that American workers have not benefited from trade
agreements (I did NOT cross over, but I also believe that the agreements have
benefited corporations at the expense of workers both at home and abroad; NAFTA
was my biggest disappointment of the Bill Clinton administration) and (2) who
want a president not beholden to the status quo.
·
Even
the anti-Hillary contingent cannot be dismissed simply as anti-woman or
anti-feminist. I voted for her but have never fully trusted either of the
Clintons since NAFTA. Be honest, my dear fellow feminists: was she your ideal
candidate? Not mine, but I voted for her because I mistrusted her opponent far,
far more on almost every issue and could not stomach his behavior or rhetoric.
·
This
brings us to racism and sexism and bigotry of all kinds. Undoubtedly,
those played a part, and undoubtedly racism persists in this country, as does
sexism and homophobia and xenophobia, etc. Unfortunately, too, the worst
segment of that contingent now feels it has a mandate to act out its hate. And
no, we cannot stand back in silence, and we cannot hide fearfully in our homes.
We must oppose hatred and bigotry and persecution wherever we find them. But
it’s important we not characterize half our country’s population on the basis
of what I have to believe is a minority splinter contingent.
Nothing in my list above is meant to excuse odious speech or behavior on the part of the candidate or any of his supporters.
But now, two conclusions I hope you will share with me: First, supporters of the
new president-elect cannot be dismissed as a monolithic demonic army of
hate-mongers. And second, to prevent the social disintegration we so deeply
fear it is important that we not build walls that would escalate divisions
and turn our beloved country into warring camps.
President
Obama never fails to amaze me, and he and the First Lady, Michelle, are the
examples I would have us take for our own. We need to do as they have always
done and continue to do: to oppose bigotry and hatred at every opportunity, to
continue to listen to others, to demand and bestow respect for and on human
beings, and to model the behavior we want to see surrounding us. I hope and fervently
pray that the hour and a half the president-elect spent with the president the
other day will have a lasting and beneficial effect on the future behavior of the
man who will next inhabit the White House. I
also hope, (somewhat desperately, I must admit: these are ugly, frightening times) that the president-elect will be inspired speak out publicly to rein in
the worst behavior of his supporters. The sooner, the better. In fact, I hope
it will have already happened before this post goes online.
